Insights

AXIOM INSIGHTS

Perspectives on private debt, commodity trade finance and liquidity from both sides of the trade.

Private Debt · Trade Finance · Liquidity & Risk · Trading Companies

Do the deal, report afterwards: making a borrowing base facility work

Do the deal, report afterwards: making a borrowing base facility work

A borrowing base gives traders flexible, revolving finance against their pool of current assets. It is only as good as the data behind it: what counts, how it is priced and verified, and how often it is reported.

A borrowing base turns stock and receivables into available credit. It is a revolving facility, usually provided by a club or syndicate of lenders for one to three years, and secured on a trader's pool of current assets rather than on individual deals. It suits businesses too granular to finance deal by deal: many small, short trades, distribution or blending. It is designed for mature traders with a track record, sound trading and control systems, reliable reporting and adequate equity.

How much can be drawn. The trader can draw the value of each eligible asset multiplied by its advance rate, and the closer an asset is to cash, the higher the rate. Drawings are capped by the facility limit and, between reports, by the latest borrowing base minus amounts already drawn.

Set the rules on day one. The borrowing base is also where many disputes start. Valuation rules, eligibility criteria, concentration limits and reporting frequency need to be clear on day one, and so do the covenants (cross-default, negative pledge, maximum debt), which are often negotiated at length, with legal opinions in each jurisdiction where assets are pledged.

Agree what counts. Cash counts only if properly pledged and held at a sound bank. Receivables are reduced for amounts the trader owes the same counterparty where netting applies, overdue or doubtful items, related-party balances and unsecured items. Damaged or illiquid inventory is excluded, and prepayments rarely count. Advance rates are higher for receivables on investment-grade buyers or backed by letters of credit or insurance rated A- or better, and lower for inventory held in difficult jurisdictions.

Figure: How much can the trader draw? — illustrative borrowing base calculation.

Figure: How much can the trader draw? — illustrative borrowing base calculation.

Price and report frequently. Price exchange-traded commodities daily and agree a reporting frequency that suits the trade: the borrowing base certificate is typically delivered weekly, twice a month or monthly. Inventory should be marked against a recognised benchmark when available — LME, LBMA, CBOT or a published assessment — with a clear basis adjustment.

Know where the goods are. Warehouse receipts are only as reliable as what stands behind them: an approved, inspected and insured warehouse, a reputable independent inspection company (such as SGS or AmSpec) verifying quantity and quality, and receipts verified directly with the issuer. Duplicate or fictitious receipts remain one of the sector's main fraud risks. Because reporting comes after the deals, third-party confirmation of each asset class is essential.

Treat receivables with care. Ageing, buyer concentration and credit insurance coverage determine what a receivable is really worth.

Secure the whole pool. Lenders take a pledge over most current assets (a UCC filing in the United States), together with a tripartite agreement covering hedging accounts and insurance proceeds. Whether that security can actually be enforced, in every jurisdiction concerned, is as important as the advance rate.

Audit, then automate. Before the first drawing, lenders audit the borrower's processes and controls. A well-built collateral management tool then reduces errors and gives both sides the same numbers at the same time, and online borrowing base reporting lets both sides follow eligibility and headroom almost in real time.

Weigh the trade-off. For the trader, a borrowing base is usually cheaper than unsecured or structured financing and far more flexible. It grows with asset values, including to meet margin calls, and turns working capital into cash sooner. The price is lower advance rates than transactional finance, enough equity to absorb the haircuts, and a significant reporting workload. For lenders, it offers short tenor, good recovery rates and fee income, provided controls and reporting are robust. The main risks to watch are weak controls, fraud, enforceability of the security, buyer and supplier credit, market risks (price, currency, interest rate and basis) and the borrower's own financial strength.

A borrowing base rewards discipline. A trader who reports accurately and on time earns flexibility; one who does not soon loses it.

Disclaimer: The content of AXIOM Insights is provided for general information only and does not constitute investment, legal or tax advice, nor an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any financial instrument. Investment solutions referred to are available only to professional and institutional clients within the meaning of the Swiss Financial Services Act (FinSA) and, where applicable, to qualified investors within the meaning of the Collective Investment Schemes Act (CISA). Past performance and target returns are not indicative of future results.

Search